The Global Experiment of the IYC 2011: Creating Online Communities for Education and Science

Authorship: 

Javier Garcia Martinez1 & Rovani Sigamoney2
1
Department of Inorganic Chemistry. University of Alicante, E-03690, Alicante, Spain j.garcia@ua.es, www.nanomol.es
2 UNESCO Division of Basic and Engineering Science r.sigamoney@unesco.org

Article Date: 
May 25, 2012 - May 31, 2012
Abstract: 

How do we make students the stars of their own learning, taking them out of the classroom for simple experiments and enabling them to share on the web, their experiences, pictures, and results? This was the main goal of the Global Experiment, addressing key objectives of IYC, namely to increase public understanding. The theme Water–A Chemical Solution was chosen to invite students to explore one of Earth’s most critical resources.

A dedicated website for the Global Experiment was designed to disseminate the experiments protocols, upload the results, view all deposit data, and share stories. The interactive site—available in English, French, Spanish, Russian, and Chinese—engaged young people to take part in celebarting IYC and to learn about the relationship between water and many of the world’s current problems—from food shortages to climate change—and how chemistry plays a fundamental role in understanding and resolving these challenges. Four experiments were designed covering acidity, salinity, filtration and distillation.

Since launching the Global Experiment on World Water Day in March 2011 in South Africa, 80 000 students from over 80 countries have shared their results on the website. Central to the success of the Global Experiment was the use of social networks, which allowed students to shared experiences, photos, and concerns in real time through Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, or Flickr. By using these social tools, students created their own communities of friends sharing interest in chemistry.

http://www.chemistry2011.org/participate/activities/show?id=92
The Global Experiment website: http://water.chemistry2011.org
Video:
http://youtu.be/mcKb9J0ZgxA

 

Article PDF: 
Video: 
See video

The Global Experiment of the International Year of Chemistry: Creating Online Communities for Education and Science

Javier Garcia Martinez & Rovani Sigamoney

One study shows that 96% of the students with online access reported that they used online social media, and nearly 60% of those students use these online tools to discuss education-related topics and more than 50% reported that they use them to discuss schoolwork to support their education. 1 Recognizing the potential risks of irresponsible use of the web, there is great potential in the new social networking technologies to reach our kids using their own language and help them find their own interests. In many cases, this simply consists of using their channels of communication to share information. In other cases, it means creating opportunities for them to share and create content that is useful for them.2 The central idea behind student-driven education is that the kids would be the main actors of their own learning by having them leave the classroom for simple experiments related to daily activities, and then enabling them to share their experiences, pictures, and results on the web.

The Global Experiment of the International Year of Chemistry,3,4,5 has been a wonderful opportunity to reach hundreds of thousands of students through social media for education and science. The various experiments were designed to require minimal equipment and resources, and the protocols drafted by an international team of educators. A dedicated website for the Global Experiment was created so that one could download the instructions for performing the experiments, upload the results, and view the data obtained by other students from around the world. The interactive site—available in English, French, Spanish, Russian, and Chinese—also served as a clearinghouse for teachers and affiliated centers. It was designed for young people to actively participate in IYC and learn about the relationship between water and many of the world’s current problems—from food shortages to climate change—and how chemistry plays a fundamental role in understanding and resolving these challenges. When all of the results of the experiment were posted by students, an impressive map began to emerge that illustrated the contributions from all schools, colleges, or institutions involved around the world.

Figure 1. Data collected by students displayed on maps that show the different values according to their value, location and number of participants.

Activities related to the measurement of water quality:

• Acidity: Students learned to take measurements of local water pH using various indicators. Next, they were taught to use techniques for checking the reliability of the results obtained.

• Salinity: The salinity experiment enabled students to measure the salt content of water samples by evaporation and until the sample is dried to constant weight.

Activities related to water purification:

• Filtration: In this activity the students constructed a filtration unit and evaluated its efficiency and capacity using a sample of local water. As with other activities, the data generated contributed to a global map of the results.

• Distillation: During this activity, students investigated an alternative way of purifying water using solar energy and the process of distillation. Additionally, students had an opportunity to design and build their own distillation system.

Social media is a powerful tool embraced by the youth and which offers new opportunities and challenges for educators to engage their students. Central to the success of the Global Experiment was the use of social networks, which allowed students to shared experiences, photos, and concerns in real time through Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, or Flickr. Using these social tools, they were able to create their own communities of friends who shared their interest in chemistry. From the beginning, the Global Experiment was intended not just as an activity for youth. Instead, with the tools that social media provided, the experiment quickly evolved to become an activity by youth—a student-driven initiative allowing interaction through virtual communities. Both the students and the teachers are to be thanked, and each school that participated in this activity received a certificate of participation.

Figure 2. Interactive tool contained in the website of the Global Experiment including Twitter, Facebook and YouTube.

Recently, the Global Experiment was part of a competition organized by Visualizing.org, in which computer programmers worldwide were asked to develop software that could view, compare, and analyze the vast amount of information we gathered over the past year.[6] In the spirit of the Global Experiment, this challenge was developed in a collaborative way so that from an initial design, programmers could create a more effective tool together than any individual programmer. The end result is an interactive map that displays all data sorted by type of experiment, the source of the water sample, and location.

Figure 3. Developed specific software for viewing, comparison and analysis of the results of Experiment Global created collaboratively by programmers around the world through the competition organized by Visualizing.org

The yearlong Global Experiment – Water: a Chemical Solution has been quite remarkable both educationally and socially. All of us in IUPAC and UNESCO are very grateful to everyone from around the world, who worked so hard to make GWE possible, but most importantly, we’d like to thank all the teachers and students who embraced the Global Experiment – they were the ones who made it truly global and made it such a success.

References:

[1] Creating & Connecting: Research and Guidelines on Online Social—and Educational—Networking. National School Boards Association. 2007.

[2] Javier Garcia-Martinez, Chemistry 2.0: Creating Online Communities, Chemistry International, Jul-Aug 2010, Vol. 32, No. 4, pp. 4-7.

[3] The Global Experiment website: water.chemistry2011.org

[4] Tony Wright y Javier Garcia Martinez, Water: A Chemical Solution - A Global Experiment for the International Year of Chemistry, Chemistry International, Sep-Oct 2010, Vol. 32 No. 5, pp 14-17.

[5] Javier Garcia Martinez, The Global Experiment for the International Year of Chemistry, Water: A Chemical Solution, Chemistry International, May-June 2012, Vol. 34 No. 3, pp 14-17.

 [6] Visualization Sprint:  www.visualizing.org/sprint/global-water-experiment or www.chemistry2011.org/about-iyc/news/GWE_sprint_visualization/

Presentation: 

Comments

Looking forward to take part in the next experiment

Javier,

It was a great project! I heard about it too late to join, but we performed some of the experiments in our class.

Do you plan to gather more information in the next year? Do you think that this experiment could go on on-line on itself?

Are you thinking about another global experiment on another theme? "what do you eat?" (maybe counting daily ammount of calories, proteins, fat & sugar)

Malka

Looking forward to take part in the next experiment

Javier,

It was a great project! I heard about it too late to join, but we performed some of the experiments in our class.

Do you plan to gather more information in the next year? Do you think that this experiment could go on on-line on itself?

Are you thinking about another global experiment on another theme? "what do you eat?" (maybe counting daily ammount of calories, proteins, fat & sugar)

Malka

moving forward

Thanks Malka for your very kind comments on the Global Water Experiment. This has been a team effort, kudos to all involved !

The website (water.chemistr2011.org) is and will be open, so people can to download the protocols and perform the different experiments as many times as they want. So far, no more data can be added to the map, but we are working on ways either to open it again, or launch a different global activity.

We will keep everybdy posted !

once again thanks for helping us engage students in Science !

Javier

Global Water Experiment

Let me add my heartfelt congratulations to Javier, Rovani and the team of colleagues who worked together to organize and implement the Global Water Experiment.  One of the central objectives of IYC was to bring chemistry to young people around the world, and give them a hands-on experience.  The GWE acheived this in a remarkable way.  I think one of the greatest long lasting impacts of GWE could be the partnerships that developed to deliver it.  It would be good to hear from anyone on the list who has ideas about how to sustain such partnerships over new global activities, so that the momentum for IYC is not lost.

Peter Mahaffy

students and social networking

Javier,

 

I have two questions.  First, on page two of your slides you state that 96% of students with online access report using social networking technologies.  Could you provide us with some more information on this.  Second, I have a refective question. If you were to go back in time and redo the GWE, what would you do different?  Although I am thinking from both science and social networking technology perspectives, I would really like to leave this as an open question.

Cheers,
Bob

students using social networking technologies

 

Bob,

Based on a survey  conducted in cooperation with the National School Boards Association and underwritten by MySpace/News Corp, Microsoft, and Verizon, nearly all (96%) of kids aged 9 – 17 are chatting, text messaging, blogging, and creating pages on social sites. You can get all the information about this survey here: http://socialnetworking.procon.org/sourcefiles/CreateandConnect.pdf

I recently published an article in Chemistry International on how to use this to engage with students and promote science education through online communities. http://www.iupac.org/publications/ci/2010/3204/1_garcia-martinez.html

On your second questions, although there are many things that I will do differently for a new Global Water Experiment, actually I would like to heard from those who took part in this activity. Personally, a priority would be to involve more people from Africa, China and Russia. 

regards,

Javier

Ref.: Water experiment, but also a goal of IYC „to increase int

Ref.: Water experiment, but also a goal of IYC „to increase interest of young poeple in chemistry“.

On behalves of a lot of pupils, students and teachers in schools around Slovakia (Europe) I wish to acknowledge the enthusiastic work of Javier and the entire GWE team. The participation to experiments locally and sharing the data worldwide was great in our country. Moreover, some “projects” of the most tackled individuals continue on national level, and form a piece of legacy of IYC in our country.
Attached link shows video (in Slovak) of our “mid-term summarisation and discussions” during “scientific cafe of youth”, in October 2011 at headquarter of the Centre of Scientific & Technical Information of Slovak Republic.
https://www.vedatechnika.sk/SK/VedaASpolocnost/NCPVaT/video/Stranky/2011...

All the best , Milan.

Assoc. Prof. RNDr. Milan DRÁBIK, PhD.
podpredseda Slovenskej Chemickej Spoločnosti pri SAV
(president-past of Slovak Chemical Society)
Chairman of the Slovak National Committee of IUPAC
T. M. of the Inorganic Chemistry Division of IUPAC
Member of the Inorganic Chemistry Division of EuCheMS
Life-member, Institute of Materials (IoM), U. K.

Department of Inorganic Chemistry
Faculty of Natural Sciences, Comenius University
(drabik@fns.uniba.sk)
&
Institute of Inorganic Chemistry - SASci
Ceramics Department
http://www.uach.sav.sk/
Dúbravská cesta 9 e-mail : uachmdra@savba.sk
845 36 Bratislava Phone : +421-2-59410474
SLOVAK REPUBLIC Fax : +421-2-59410444

“scientific cafe of youth”

Dear Milan,

Thanks a lot for your very kind email. Indeed the GWE has been possible thanks to a very devoted group of inviduals, our sponsors, and thousands of teachers and students from all around the World. 

I really enjoyed your video (although I couldn´t understand a word). I saw you presenting the map of your country from our website with the data shared by different schools. As I told you during the IYC closing ceremony, Slovakia has been one of the most active countries in Europe. Thanks a lot for all you and your colleagues have done.

It will be really nice if you could post your video in youtube, so I could add it to the Facebook group of the Global Experiments.

best regards,

Javier

Creating Online Communities for Education and Science

Dear Javier & Rovani,

I appreciate very much your team’s effort in engaging “student-driven” activities using today’s developed global IT technologies. Involved youngsters are the lucky ones. However, as a member of the elders’ group, I was thinking today’s adults are less fortunate. They didn’t experience the speedy and convenient fb network when they were young and as they are part of us, they should also receive decent attention (in fact their population is growing). The reason I mention this is because I notice many 50s or 60s do not eat wisely and are suffering from poor heath which they don’t even notice! Had they come across information like balanced diet and food chemistry when they were still young, they would have been more alert to the food they put into their mouths. This actually is a good news for the government, especially the health department. Having said that, I wonder who should bear the responsibility.

I hope what I’ve mentioned is in line with the theme of your paper “Creating Online Communities for Education and Science”

Keep the good work going!

KM Chan

creating online communities for the "elders’ group"

Thanks a lot KM Chan for your kind comments and interest in our paper,

In general, I agree with your comments, but you will be surprised how many people in their 50s and 60s are in FB, Twitter and many other social sities. It takes from commitment but the benefits are quite remarkable. Doing something on healthy eating is a great idea. In fact there are already some groups with thousands of members:

http://www.facebook.com/pages/Healthy-eating/106462099390383

http://www.facebook.com/pages/healthy-eating/8241350981

regards,

Javier

 

Facebook distributions & global project water quality questions

Hi

I find this very interesting and wish to add a few comments/questions. Regading facebook users - there is a website giving such a breakdown:

http://www.kenburbary.com/2011/03/facebook-demographics-revisited-2011-statistics-2/

Also take a look at the article which in its title includes "Dispelling the youth myth ...."

http://www.kenburbary.com/2010/01/dispelling-the-youth-myth-five-useful-facebook-demographic-statistics/

Here we also need to examine the age distribution within each country to compare and make any meaningful comments about such facebook age distributions.

Regarding the global water project I noticed there is no data for countries like Russia or China? Also in the visualization the average pH is just over 7.0 as expected but has there been questions (and hopefully answers) asked of those places within the US or UK for example that have either very acidic conditions or very alkaline conditions? I think I saw one of these very acidic points to be a sample of data collected by 2 students? Does this mean  2 samples? etc. Was there repeat sampling? Was there repeat testing of the samples etc.? How are these data being looked at: Are these outliers, suspect outliers, influential data points, true data points. Often the most interesting data are those that seem to be so completely different to the average/ or median set of values.

Thanks.

Ling

Ling Huang, Sacramento City College

 

 

 

the most interesting data are those that seem to be so completel

Dear Ling,

Thanks for your interesting links and comments regarding the GWE and the use of FB to engage with the youth. 

I found specially interesting your point about "the most interesting data are those that seem to be so completely different to the average". I fully agree wth this observation. In fact, when I interacted with the students that perform some of these experiments (many times through FB) they were in fact looking for "unusual sources of water" like hot spring or sites with extreme pH values due to different natural causes. This gave them the opportunity to learn more about water, chemistry and "average values" and their meaning.

regards,

Javier

Virtual Experiments

Some years ago, Georgia Tech had an online aquarium with a lot more than video cameras.  It had many sensors including pH, CO2,  and Ion Chromatography.

The data were archived and at least some of it could be retrieved.

It is unfortunate that it is gone, because it provided resources which anybody in the world could use, with classes or just for personal edification.

I hope that others will see fit to bring about projects like this for the world chemical education community.

<Richard>

Richard Pendarvis, Ph.D.

Brenau University Chemistry

the future of global experiment

Dear Javier,

Starting from the very beginning you and your colleagues have achieved a wonderful success in GWE. I know that GWE took enormous attention throughout the world. I am wondering is it possible to give us some figures about the continuity of the interest to GWE after the IYC 2011 was over. Is there any students who are using the web site?

A second question is about possibility of using the same templete (web page) for other global experiments. How easy to use the web site for other experiments?

Regards

Mustafa SOZBILIR

GWE impact

Thanks Mustafa for your kind comments and relevant questions,

 

As you can read in our recent article in Chemistry International http://www.iupac.org/publications/ci/2012/3403/3_martinez.html almost 130,000 students from 80 countries used our website and actually shared data and helped us build the global map. But many more participated without registering in our website. We estimate that 2 million people took part in the Global Experiment of the IYC.

Regarding you second question, I fully agree that we should use what we already built as a foundation for future global activities... I will be talking more about this in Rome this summer during our meeting.

best regards,

Javier

 

Social Media in Academia

Dear Javier, Rovani, Lida, Mei-Hung and Erica,

I note that your Global Water Experiment and the YAC project both use Facebook, and I realize much of this is to communicate between faculty and not students.  Please pardon me, but my question does not so much deal with the Global Water Experiment or YAC, but the evolving role of social media in education.

Yesterday I heard an Interesting NPR (National Public Radio - USA) report which I thought might raise an eyebrow, http://www.npr.org/blogs/alltechconsidered/2012/05/24/153610087/friend-your-students-new-york-city-schools-say-no

In a nutshell, NYC schools have issued "Social Media Guidelines"

http://schools.nyc.gov/NR/rdonlyres/BCF47CED-604B-4FDD-B752-DC2D81504478/0/DOESocialMediaGuidelines20120430.pdf

Here is a cut and paste from the New York City Department of Education guidelines:

E. Personal Social Media Use
1. Communication with DOE Students
In order to maintain a professional and appropriate relationship with students, DOE employees should not communicate [8] with students who are currently enrolled in DOE schools on personal social media sites. This provision is subject to the following exceptions: (a) communication with relatives and (b) if an emergency situation requires such communication, in which case the DOE employee should notify his/her supervisor of the contact as soon as possible.

[8] Examples of such communications include, but are not limited to, “friending,” “following,” “commenting,” and posting messages.

I myself barely use Facebook as I just don't have the time, but this sure looks like it would discourage its use in academia.  Now, I realize this is not a fair question to ask the authors, but do the authors or other participants have input on this? Does the use of social media in education need to be regulated? Are other countries adapting similar policies?

Cheers,
Bob

FB for Science Education

Bob,

Actually I have an opposite opinion  (http://www.iupac.org/publications/ci/2010/3204/1_garcia-martinez.html)

Please notice that accordingly to a survey of over 1200 students organized by the National School Boards Association in the USA, 9- to 17-year olds in the USA spend 10 hours a week watching TV compared to 9 hours a week on web-based social networking activities. However, when our kids network online, they are much more active and innovative—creating content, sharing information, and blogging—than when they watch TV.

In the USA, an astonishing 96 percent of students who have online access report that they have used social networking technologies. And it’s not all about sharing music or organizing a plan for next weekend. Nearly 60 percent of our students use social networking to discuss education-related topics, and more than 50 percent specifically discuss schoolwork to support their education

Creating & Connecting: Research and Guidelines on Online Social—and Educational—Networking. National School Boards Association. 2007."

This has been confirmed after being in touch with thousands of people over the years in FB (both in the IYC FB group as well as the GWE FB group):

http://www.facebook.com/groups/128264461150/

http://www.facebook.com/groups/141490222561350/

regards,

Javier